A Vet's Review of Physicians Mutual Pet Insurance
2024

by Frances Wilkerson, DVM

This review discusses the 5 important pieces of coverage and payout structure

To get the most from this review, please read the Guide to Pet Insurance first.
For a detailed look at Physicians Mutual, see Physicians Mutual's Comparison Sheet.



Overview

Physicians Mutual has offered pet insurance since 2022.

This review refers to Physicians Mutual's plans that have accident and illness coverage: Economy, Standard, and Preferred Plans



Coverage Overview

In general, Physicians Mutual Pet Insurance covers diagnostics and lab tests, surgery, treatments, and hospitalization for eligible accidents/injuries and illnesses as long as the condition is not pre-existing, has not occurred during the waiting period, and you have not reached your maximum payout.

Certain plans do not cover exam fees unless you purchase the exam fee addon.

Certain plans do not cover prescription drug fees unless you purchase the prescription drug addon.

Dental coverage for accidents and illnesses is limited.



Coverage For Chronic Diseases & Continual Coverage For Chronic Diseases

Physicians Mutual Pet Insurance covers chronic diseases and provides continual coverage for chronic conditions as long as the condition is not pre-existing, has not occurred during the waiting period, and you have not reached your maximum payout.



Hereditary & Congenital Coverage

Hereditary, congenital, breed-specific and genetic conditions, including hip dysplasia are covered by Physicians Mutual Pet Insurance as long as the condition is not pre-existing, has not occurred during the waiting period, and you have not reached your maximum payout.



Cancer Coverage

Physicians Mutual Pet Insurance covers cancer conditions as long as the condition is not pre-existing, has not occurred during the waiting period, and you have not reached your maximum payout.



Coverage For Breed Specific Conditions

Physicians Mutual Pet Insurance covers breed specific medical conditions, as long as the condition is not pre-existing, has not occurred during the waiting period, and you have not reached your maximum payout.



Maximum Payout Structure

Physicians Mutual Pet Insurance has an annual maximum payout structure. Their different plans have different maximum annual payouts ($5,000, $7,500, $10,000, $12,500, $15,000, $20,000, $25,000 and Unlimited). These options of maximum payout will meet everyone's calculated "Worst Case Scenario Costs". (See: Picking the Right Maximum Payout)



Summary of Coverage and Payout Structure

Limitations

  • With certain plans, to get Prescription Drug and Exam Fee coverage you must remember to purchase the add ons
  • This company has additional Injury and Illness situations that will be deemed pre-existing. See sample policy or contact the company for a complete description.
  • 6 month waiting period Orthopedic-Related Conditions, this includes hip dysplasia. May vary by state.

    While the orthopedic waiting period can be waived by submitting a Orthopedic Waiver Form completed by a Veterinarian, please note that a Vet may want additional diagnostics (e.g. x-rays, ultrasound, etc) before they will feel comfortable certifying this. The cost of this will be out of your own pocket.
  • Dental coverage for accidents and illness is limited


Good Points

  • Offers a variety of annual max payouts that will meet most people's "Worst Case Scenario Costs"
  • Provides comprehensive coverage in the 5 important areas as part of the base plan:
    1. Chronic disease
    2. Continual coverage for chronic disease
    3. Hereditary/congenital conditions
    4. Cancer
    5. Breed specific conditions


Concerns

  • Contact Physicians Mutual Pet Insurance for information on the specific reasons they may cancel a policy. Given that Nationwide unexpectedly announced the cancellation of over 100,000+ policies in the spring of 2024, it's important to have clarity in this area.
  • Physicians Mutual Pet Insurance plans are newer. Based on what I've seen since 2008, it can take time for a company to settle in on consistent premium pricing and policy terms.
  • If a bilateral condition happens on one side before they policy starts or during the waiting period, that condition will not be covered if it happens on the other side. Even if it happens after the waiting period. Their Bilateral Conditions policy doesn't clearly list the medical conditions or body systems that fall under this exclusion.

    There are so many body systems that inhabit both sides of the body (e.g. eyes, ears, knees, hips, front paws, elbows, toenails, kidneys, lungs, femur, etc). Not clearly defining which systems they are referring to leaves a big door open that could allow them to deem something as a bilateral exclusion whenever they see fit. Letting customers know what specific conditions and/or systems fall under this exclusion would be much more transparent. Even if they want the definition to include all body systems that inhabit both sides of the body, it is important that they clearly let the customer know this.
  • Based on their pre-existing conditions policy, signs and symptoms can be used to denote something as pre-existing. As with all pet insurance companies that use this wording, I have concerns that this can be used to deny claims even when these previous signs/symptoms are not directly related to the disease or condition currently in question.



Additional Comments Regarding All Pet Insurance Companies:

  • Make sure you research what customers are saying about the company. A company may have the 5 components that should be part of a pet insurance plan, but the company may not be a hit with customers. Sites to check include but are not limited to: BBB.org, Yelp.com and PetInsuranceReview.com. Things to look for include but are not limited to: How fast are payments paid?, What are customers saying about the pre-existing conditions policy?, How often are claims denied and for what reason?, What is the customer service experience like?, Are there issues with premium increases?
  • Check with your state's Department of Insurance to see if any complaints have been filed for the company you are interested in.
  • Make sure you understand what the waiting periods are.
  • Make sure you understand their bilateral conditions policy.
  • Make sure you understand any requirements that you must adhere to to maintain coverage.
  • Make sure you read the terms and conditions to get a thorough understanding of all exclusions.
  • Make sure you understand when and by how much your premium can increase.
  • If you change plan levels, there is a possibility that all medical conditions present under the old plan will be considered pre-existing in the new plan. Make sure you ask the company if this is the case.
  • For some companies, pre-existing conditions can be based on signs and symptoms alone, a diagnosis is not needed. For example, if your pet had a cough before you applied for pet insurance and this cough was discussed and written in the pet's medical record, there is the possibility that all future cough conditions, no matter what the cause, would be considered pre-existing - even if there was no treatment given. Make sure you ask the company if this is the case.
  • Pet insurance companies are businesses. The top priority of any business is to make a profit for their stakeholders. Pet insurance companies can and may change your rates and terms to meet that top priority. A change of business ownership or underwriters can also be a catalyst for changes in your rates and terms.

    When you purchase pet insurance make sure you have a realistic understanding of this and how it can affect you.


Additional Reviews:

24PetProtect | AKC | ASPCA | Bivvy | Companion Protect | Doggo | Embrace | Felix | Fetch | Figo | Hartville | Healthy Paws | Lemonade | Liberty Mutual | ManyPets | MetLife | Nationwide | Odie | Petco | Pet Partners | Pets Best | Physicians Mutual | Prudent Pet | Pumpkin | Spot | Toto | Trupanion | Wagmo


**Disclaimer: This review is meant to supplement, not replace your own due diligence. Terms and conditions can vary from state to state. Before buying a pet insurance plan, confirm all information by contacting the company or reading the most current policy for your state. We will not be held liable for errors or omissions. If you see something that is incorrect or needs clarifying, please let me know.

**Copyright: You are more than welcome to link to this website, in fact, it is greatly appreciated. However, a lot of time, energy and effort went into the production of this material so please do not copy and paste the contents of this website into your website or written material.

If you use data from this website as a research point for your own website or written material, you must cite Pet-Insurance-University.com as the source.

All names, logos and trademarks in this site are the property of their respective owner(s).

Top